It seems obvious that this is necessary, as a contribution to the Blogger Community that I joined in June 2000 or thereabouts. Google bought Blogger c 2013, and since then I have noticed concerning trends, especially in recent years. Accordingly, under fair comment doctrine:
1: Of course, anyone can claim an interest in free debate and fair discussion, however when I had a problem with false and malicious accusation, I had to turn off comment and when attack blogs continued, Google told me I would have to get court orders for them to stop anything, back c 2013 - 15. So far as I know, the accusers are still at it.
2: Accusation has been made easy, and so far as I can see my only recourse to communicate a defence is to send a courier packet to Google physically, with no response from them. Accordingly, let me draw attention to a natural law principle put on record when the Jerusalem authorities wanted Paul taken to Jerusalem, in a request to a new Governor. This was Festus' remark:
Ac 25:16 I answered them that it was not the custom of the Romans to give up anyone before the accused met the accusers face to face and had opportunity to make his defense concerning the charge laid against him.
3: This, is an obvious standard, right of reasonable response, in a context of specific accusation that is factually, logically answerable. Fair comment: Google is failing this test and that accordingly frames how the substance (so much of it that is there) of the policy is evaluated -- in a world where Wikipedia is a notorious case of activist capture.
4: Adult content: I have never posted obscene materials at Google, but Sept 28 was falsely, vaguely accused of "Adult content." On the last thing I put up principle, I stopped relying on the caption and context [where an image is embedded] and revised an image I used to expose Hitler as a blasphemous false and destructive political messiah figure. I attached a yellow post it note that explained. I put point by point comments in the expanded image, this led to restoration -- again without explanation. So far as I know, the face of Hitler, the Swastika [which has many legitimate uses] -- which I pointed out in context as a twisted broken cross, an army of the deluded, a demonic bomber bird in a burst of light through clouds and the Rhine valley are not sexual content.
5: Child abuse: I suspect, an extension of point 4. This is an issue out there, though I would be very interested to see how those adhering to evolutionary materialistic scientism found moral government, bridging the is-ought gap in the roots of reality that is the only place where the Euthyphro dilemma and Hume's guillotine can be answered, with the best explanation answer being the inherently good, utterly wise creator God.
6: Dangerous and illegal activities: vague again, and of course needing reality root level anchorage, e.g. is fishing or hunting a violation? If animals are reckoned to be at the level of humans, on what base? If humans are reduced to blind animality, that opens the door to abuses. This is Schaeffer's "man is a zero" concern. We need civilisational reformation before we go over a cliff -- something that recently literally happened to me thanks to oil slick and hydroplaning, I do not recommend the experience, literal or metaphorical. Fair comment clip (with apologies to real Lemmings):
7: Fraud: Again, yes, but on what reality root basis? (Do you begin to see where selective hyperskepticism, marginalisation of objectivity of core moral knowledge and linked activism lead?)
8: Harassment: Yes, same basis question of course. Also, what happened when I was being targetted and falsely accused?
9: Hate speech: This is one of those terms with a swivel, easily twisted into protecting agendas that can be seriously objected to on principle from reasonable, responsible, principled challenge, thence censorship. This policy term has no protection for principled critique; one is obviously needed in an age where activists target at will, including using the wicked claim "speech is violence" to respond to fair critique and debate with physical attack and mob tactics.
10: Misrepresentation and Identity theft or doxxing: Where was this when I was targetted like this, please?
11: Malware: Such as, hello world based open code? My latest vague accusation.
12: Misleading: another open door to censorship. I come from a country where election violence and fraud have been actual, likely unfinished, history; where, digitalisation of elections and promotion of less secure correspondence voting has opened a gap between voters and votes as well as the actual counted ballots -- for cause, I advocate same day, paper ballot voting with scrutineers in close proximity, with two-factor photo ID control against responsible electoral lists with only a very strict allowance for some correspondence remote voting. I have similarly, low confidence in digital security in a world with secret agency backed hacking and obvious widespread surveillance state concerns. Further to this, it is not empty speculation to ask pointed questions and raise concerns on veils of secrecy. Similarly, there is a whole world of alternative health concerns out there in a day when big pharma has come under serious question.
13: Censorship: this lurks beneath many of the points raised.
I trust this is sufficient as "a word to the wise." END
